What to print first & why
Start with the three things customers actually touch: menus, loyalty punch cards, and business cards. A fresh printed menu quietly raises your average ticket — people order the lavender latte when it's listed beautifully instead of scrawled on a chalkboard footnote. Loyalty punch cards are the cheapest retention tool in your whole shop; a card in the wallet is a reason to walk past the competitor. Business cards go next to the register for catering and wholesale inquiries. Then layer in die-cut stickers (cup decoration, laptop marketing that walks around town for free) and a vinyl banner for your patio or grand-opening energy.
What it actually costs
Real numbers, no asterisks: menus run $229 for 1,000 — enough to reprint seasonally without guilt. Loyalty punch cards are $54.99 for 500. Business cards start at $39.95/100, $44.95/250, $54.99/500. Die-cut stickers are $139/250 or $219/500 — customers genuinely collect these. A 2×6 vinyl banner is $59; the 3×8 is $89. Want to tell the whole neighborhood about your new location? EDDM postcards start at $398 per mail route — printing AND mailing to roughly 400–800 nearby homes. Barista tees for the team? From $9.40 each at 144. Every price includes shipping.
How it works
Upload your design — or the closest thing you've got — and our team runs a free pro file check to catch blurry logos, off-size art, and colors that would print muddy. Then you get a free digital proof showing exactly what your piece will look like. Nothing is charged until you approve that proof, so there are zero “wait, that's not what I ordered” moments. Shipping is included in every price you see. And if something arrives wrong on our end, our reprint guarantee means we make it right. Upload, approve, brew.
Frequently asked questions
How much does it cost to print menus for a coffee shop?
Printed cafe menus cost $229 for 1,000 at i Can Print That, with shipping included in that price. That volume lets you update seasonally — new fall drinks, holiday specials — without rationing copies. Every order includes a free pro file check and a free digital proof, and nothing is charged until you approve the proof.
Are loyalty punch cards worth it for a cafe?
Yes — they're one of the highest-ROI print pieces a coffee shop can buy. Loyalty punch cards cost $54.99 for 500, so each card costs pennies while giving regulars a concrete reason to return. A card in a customer's wallet is daily, free advertising. Shipping is included, and you approve a free digital proof before anything prints.
What marketing materials should a new coffee shop print first?
Start with menus ($229/1,000), business cards ($39.95/100), and loyalty punch cards ($54.99/500). Add a vinyl banner for visibility — a 3x6 is $75 — and die-cut stickers ($139/250) for cups and giveaways. To announce your opening, EDDM postcards start at $398 per route and include printing plus mailing to about 400–800 nearby homes.
How do I advertise my coffee shop to the local neighborhood?
EDDM (Every Door Direct Mail) is the most direct route: your postcard goes to every mailbox on a chosen postal route — roughly 400–800 homes — starting at $398 per route, with printing and mailing both included. Pair it with 4x6 promo postcards at $59/100 or $109/500 for handing out in-store and at farmers markets.
Will I see a proof before my cafe's menus print?
Always. Every order gets a free professional file check plus a free digital proof, and nothing is charged until you approve it. That applies whether you're ordering $229 menus, $39.95 business cards, or a $59 banner. Shipping is already included in every listed price, and a reprint guarantee backs every order.
🌮
🍺
🏡